Give us a call

Client Portal Access

Logan Office

Phone: 740-385-3150

Brimner Insurance Agency was started in 1933 by Arlie Brimner.  It began primarily as a life insurance agency with Liberty Life and Mutual of Omaha and was located on N. Market St. in Logan Ohio. Both Arlie and his wife Mae ran the agency for many years until their son Luther R. Brimner took over in the early 1960’s expanding to multiple lines of business primarily with Grange Mutual Ins. 

Luther’s son David began working with his father in 1988 and he and his wife Nancy took over in 2002. The agency has moved numerous times but was located on E Main St. for over 50 years. In 2014 it moved once again and is now back near its original location on N Market St. Is it now a full service agency representing numerous companies and all types of insurance. 



Dave Brimner

740-385-3150 ext. 702


Mary Hale

740-385-3150 ext. 701


Barb Wright

740-385-3150 ext. 703



Our Locations

Westerville Office

63 Commerce Park Drive
Westerville, OH 43082
Main office: 614-505-4033
Toll free: (800) 935-2335
Fax: 614-882-2340

Circleville Office

448 North Court Street
Circleville, OH 43113
Main office: 740-204-7218
Fax: 740-477-2701

Grove City Office

3793 Broadway
Grove City, OH 43123
Main office: 614-482-4058
Fax: 614-871-1299

Logan Office

67 North Market Street
Logan, Oh 43138
Main office: 740-204-7190
Fax: 740-385-1669

Newark Office

1335 Granville Road
Newark, Oh 43055
Main office: 740-204-7285
Fax: 740-344-3212

Pickerington Office

12927 Stonecreek Drive
Pickerington, Oh 43147
Main office: 614-548-8122
Fax: 614-866-7822

Xenia Office

508 North Detroit Street
Xenia, OH 45385
Main office: 937-813-6344
Fax: 937-372-2380

Our Providers


“I have been a client of Associated for about four years. Their customer service is unmatched when it comes to claims – we have had both auto and home claims with all of the recent wind damage in Columbus. Our agent Geoff Bishop is always looking out for our best interests, and our premium is LESS than it was with the company we switched from – with better coverage. I highly recommend them.”

Daniel D - Columbus, OH
“Best insurance company in Westerville! I have used Associated Insurance since 2003 when I started my own pest control business. Bill Bishop and Tim Bowers have helped me grow my business by managing my risk. They have kept their rates very low, but the customer service is where they shine from the competition.”

Anonymous - Westerville, OH
“I have worked with Associated Insurance and Geoff Bishop for several years. They provide great rates, super customer service (I have teenagers that keep learning to drive!!). They handle my autos and home. They go out of their way to find the right coverage and keep it accurate and up to date. Thanks Associated!”

Anonymous - Ohio